Ultraviolet

Key Quotes from Fratelli Tutti: Part 2 (Chapters 5-8)

Socialism is not a principle that is consistent in Catholic teaching. Neither is funding a multi-generational welfare culture.
Ultraviolet

LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS ON "TRADITIONIS CUSTODES" - written by a Priest and Canon Lawyer

...a proper interpretation of Session 7 Canon 13 of the DOGMATIC Council of Trent, instead of some mindless nabob simply referencing it, @Defeat Modernism As I recall, you tend to do reference this whenever you don't know what you're talking about and don't have anything better to say.
Ultraviolet

This is perfectly okay and normal to see in a NO church but TLM is evil

Nah, @mccallansteve just another misguided soul, the product of our times, whose chin won't catch Covid thanks to its Fauci Face Diaper
Ultraviolet

Francis Used Chainsaw Against Traditional Catholics

That moment when you realize even disreputable characters like Cupich and Tobin are appalled with Francis' decision.
Ultraviolet

Key Quotes from Fratelli Tutti: Part 1 (Chapters 1-4)

I'm not sure you'll say "well said" about this @Servant Of Divine Mercy but the truth compels me to say it. That's a fallacy of a False Dilemma. First, Father Matthew isn't a heretic, not according to The Church's definition of the word. Second, he isn't "playing games with everyone's souls" because that implies a.) Fr. Matthew knows the truth and b.) Fr. Matthew is choosing to lead people …More
I'm not sure you'll say "well said" about this @Servant Of Divine Mercy but the truth compels me to say it. That's a fallacy of a False Dilemma. First, Father Matthew isn't a heretic, not according to The Church's definition of the word. Second, he isn't "playing games with everyone's souls" because that implies a.) Fr. Matthew knows the truth and b.) Fr. Matthew is choosing to lead people away from the truth he privately recognizes. Meaning, you've posited only two alternatives, and in this case both are false.

Based on his writing, it seems clear Father Matthew genuinely believes in what he is writing. If I am correct, that means Father Matthew may be advancing error, but he does so in an honest fashion. Thus he doesn't know the truth (which you've very aptly and succintly stated) and he isn't choosing to lead people away from it.

Likewise, error is not heresy. If I had a dollar for every time someone on GTV misapplied the word "heresy" or "heretic" to someone they disagreed with, I could buy enough RedBull. to last the next ten years, -even at my rate of consumption.

I doubt Father Matthew will find my defense of him any more to his liking than you will, but so be it. I'm not trying to win popularity contests, merely lead souls away from error, regardless of who's advancing it.
Ultraviolet

Statement on the Motu Proprio «Traditionis Custodes» - By Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke

Disobeying the Pope, breaking Canon Law and getting excommunicated isn't "an heroic act of resistance" and there wasn't any "need" for Abp. Lefebvre to do so in the first place. The truth is, his faith failed him. Other traditionalist groups trust in God and still manage to get their priests ordained without placing themselves outside The Church.

...and no, Abp. Lefebvre's disobedience didn't …More
Disobeying the Pope, breaking Canon Law and getting excommunicated isn't "an heroic act of resistance" and there wasn't any "need" for Abp. Lefebvre to do so in the first place. The truth is, his faith failed him. Other traditionalist groups trust in God and still manage to get their priests ordained without placing themselves outside The Church.

...and no, Abp. Lefebvre's disobedience didn't "save the Traditional Mass". There were Catholic priests not part of his society who WERE still saying the Latin Mass and there are Catholic priests who aren't SSPX who ARE still saying the Latin Mass. You're just trying to re-write history to justify an act of outright schism.

You SSPX guys are always trying to "legitimize" your founder with one gimmick like this after another. It shows that you, yourselves realize how far outside The Church you've placed yourselves and you're trying, as always, to have it both ways. Pretending not to be schismatics so you can sucker in real Catholics while behavning in daily practice, exactly like the schismatics you were, are, and always shall be.

This is just another example of it. Just one problem... Cardinal Burke remains loyal to The Church and submissive to The Pope. Arhchbishop Lefebvre did not. Cardinal Burke may be a determined adversary of Francis' policies but he obeys the chain of command. Archbishop Lefebvre did not just as he didn't trust God to provide for his society after he was gone.. No, he had to "fix" things while he was alive because he didn't trust God would do so and he went about it the same way Martin Luther did.

Denying an Archbishop the right to ordain his flunkies isn't an "unspeakable abuse of power" and it isn't "locking up our Patrimony". It's Vatican politics, to be sure, but that's part of The Church and always has been.

The Patrimony of the Catholic Church belongs to The Church and those loyal to her, not to law-breaking schismatics who go their own way.

..and all the Big Bold Text Blocks aren't going to change that.

"Knowing their treachery as he did, from having been at the 2nd Vatican Council, and his ongoing, ignored petitions for Bishops,..."

Worth reminding everyone that "Saint Lefebvre" spent twenty years abiding by Vatican Council II reforms without any especial moral outrage.

His "heroism" happened only when he didn't get what he wanted. Behaving like a spoiled child isn't "heroism" and The Church doesn't canonize people for that either.

So no, Cardinal Burke isn't stating "the precise principle upon which Archbishop Lefebvre based his decision".

Lefebvre's principle was a simple one. "If I can't get what I want by obeying , then I'm just going to get what I want by breaking it."

That's the logic of every criminal.

Sadly, Cardinal Burke himself is forgetting one thing. Pope Francis hasn't denied priests the right to celebrate the Latin Mass nor has he eradicated any liturgical discipline. What Francis has done is authorize Bishops to do so and made it clear he strongly approves of them doing just that..

Francis is rivalling satan himself in cleverness. At least the devil made Jesus a straight offer: "All these will I give thee, if falling down thou wilt adore me." (Matthew 4:9)

Francis does the Prince of Lies one better. He offers the bishops nothing. But those who fancy themselves as future Cardinals will gladly "adore Francis" and implement his policies hoping to gain his favor.

"(Ref: Cardinal Burke who agrees)."

No, he doesn't. Cardinal Burke hasn't said the SSPX was all you, your friends and family had. You did.

He also didn't say your parishes were abandoning the Faith and the Masses were circuses. You did. Quit shoving your words in Cardinal Burke's mouth and a schismatic Archbishop's "position" under his name.

Cardinal Burke is not Archbishop Lefebvre. His position is different, his way of coping with modernism is different, his views are different.

This is a shameless attempt to legitimize the schismatic Lefebvre by associating him with a loyal Catholic Cardinal. Using Cardinal Burke in this fashion is nothing less than a disgusting agenda-driven sham.
Ultraviolet

Key Quotes from Fratelli Tutti: Part 2 (Chapters 5-8)

"The broader objective should be to allow them (the poor) a dignified life through work." -and what of the lazy ones who simply find it easier to game the system? They get "help" and they don't have to work.
Ultraviolet

Crucifixion: It’s Not Ancient History Anymore | National Review

It probably appeals to their sense of irony. The Church will have to wait until they start killing Buddhists before the UN does anything.
Ultraviolet

Philippine bishops support pope’s letter on traditional liturgies

...and this is why Cardinal Tagle is next in line for the Papacy. You heard it here first.
Ultraviolet

Cardinal Kasper Responds to Pope Francis’ New Motu Proprio on the Mass

It's not for the laity to decide heresy. You're throwing the term around with the same recklessness and ignorance that defines Lutheran rhetoric.
Ultraviolet

Statement on the Motu Proprio «Traditionis Custodes» - By Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke

Cardinal Burke hasn't broken Canon Law or cited a fabricated "necessity" for doing so. Thus, his position is not the same as Abp. Lefebvre's @Ave Crux
Ultraviolet

Abuse Hoax Again: “Cover-Up” Accusations Were FALSE

That furtive scratching sound you hear are all the media rats scurrying back in their holes now that this isn't "news-worthy".
Ultraviolet

Will the attack on The Latin Mass backfire? An interview with Robert Moynihan

Persecution tends to have that effect. Witness the early Christian Church.
Ultraviolet

Key Quotes from Fratelli Tutti: Part 1 (Chapters 1-4)

The Quran isn't technically a "gospel" though @Kevin --because it isn't about the life of Christ or His teachings.As you know, it denies the divinity of Christ and has little to say about Him.
Ultraviolet

Key Quotes from Fratelli Tutti: Part 1 (Chapters 1-4)

"a One-World-Religion" and "the one world religion" are not the same as you well know, Father. ;-) Overliteralism is a cop-out. Fratelli Tutti is not about making the world Catholic and I believe you're intelligent enough to realize that. It's pantheistic ecumenism, little else.
Ultraviolet

Pope’s ruling puts Latin Mass ‘in holding pattern’

It's been there for a long, long time. What's bugging El Francesco is that Catholics are making the switch to the EF and he can't stand that.
Ultraviolet

LifeSiteNews launches fundraiser to move contemplative nuns from urban hell to rural retreat

...and by "disobedience" you actually mean schism an excommunication @cmoulthrop Here's a nice big cup of "nope" for you. :P
Ultraviolet

Archbishop Viganò: Vaccines made with fetal tissue are a ‘human sacrifice of innocent victims …

In a religious sense, the Archbishop is incorrect. These particular types of vaccine were and are a purely secular political tool to legitimize and justify abortion to the "everyday person".
Ultraviolet

Reflections on Pope Francis’s Motu Proprio "Traditionis Custodes" - The European Conservative

"There exists a limit to the force even the most powerful may apply without destroying themselves. Judging this limit is the true artistry of government. Misuse of power is the fatal sin. The law cannot be a tool of vengeance, never a hostage, nor a fortification against the martyrs it has created." -Frank Herbert.
Ultraviolet

Trans madness and children - New film exposes the horror and why we should be hopeful

Short Version. Most will never "pass" as their new gender "above the waist". Surgical results "below the waist" are a disaster.