en.news
2152.6K

Benedict XVI Read Traditionis Custodes "With Pain in His Heart"

Benedict XVI read Francis' Traditionis custodes "with pain in his heart", Archbishop Gänswein told BenedictusXvi.org (2 January).

The measure was a "break" for Benedict, he said who had wanted to give Roman-Rite Catholics "inner peace" with Summorum Pontificum (2007).

Gänswein added that for centuries the Roman Mass had been the "source of spiritual life" for many people and "nourishment for many saints". He could not imagine "that it is something that is no longer any good".

That applies to "many young people" who "don't really understand the whole fuss about the Council any more." Gänswein is "not entirely" comfortable with taking this treasure away from people.

Picture: © FSSP.org, #newsXvfttampit

01:34


Wilma Lopez shares this
2303
Guido Horst (editor at Die Tagespost): "As Pope Emeritus, [Benedict] was around to see the promulgation of Pope Francis's motu proprio «Traditionis custodes». Was he disappointed?"
Archbishop Gänswein: "It hit him pretty hard. I believe it broke Pope Benedict's heart to read the new motu proprio, because his intention had been to help those who simply found a home in the old Mass to find inner peace …More
Guido Horst (editor at Die Tagespost): "As Pope Emeritus, [Benedict] was around to see the promulgation of Pope Francis's motu proprio «Traditionis custodes». Was he disappointed?"
Archbishop Gänswein: "It hit him pretty hard. I believe it broke Pope Benedict's heart to read the new motu proprio, because his intention had been to help those who simply found a home in the old Mass to find inner peace, to find liturgical peace, in order to draw them away from Lefebvre. And if you think about how many centuries the old Mass was the source of spiritual life and nourishment for many people, including many saints, it's impossible to imagine that it no longer has anything to offer. And let's not forget that many young people who were born long after Vatican II and who don't really understand all the drama surrounding the Council - that these young people, knowing the new Mass, have nevertheless found a spiritual home, a spiritual treasure in the old Mass as well. To take this treasure away from people - well, I can't say I'm comfortable with that."
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
How can good, faithful Traditional Catholics work to bring Pope Francis and his people down? I'd be glad to help organize.......I've been on this site alot since Christmas, and especially since Pope Benedict XVI became ill and unfortunatly died......but I go back to work on 1/9/2023---back teahcing H.S. after a nice Dec.23-1/8 break.
Credo .
Learn how to spell first? 😂 😂 😂
V.R.S.
Lifting restrictions on the Mass that according to own words of Benedict XVI has never been abrogated? Wait a minute: let's duc in altum - something is fishy here! No, let us better talk that Vatican apartments needed a plumber after the JPII's death.
At least Msgr. Georg Opus Dei Gaenswein is honest enough here to admit that Summorum Pontificum was intended to "draw people away from Lefebvre".
It …More
Lifting restrictions on the Mass that according to own words of Benedict XVI has never been abrogated? Wait a minute: let's duc in altum - something is fishy here! No, let us better talk that Vatican apartments needed a plumber after the JPII's death.

At least Msgr. Georg Opus Dei Gaenswein is honest enough here to admit that Summorum Pontificum was intended to "draw people away from Lefebvre".
It is one of many paradoxes in the J. Ratzinger's (R.I.P.) life that in fact it helped people to... cease fearing Msgr. Lefebvre and his priests, in particular when the Pachamama Pandemic moment had arrived.

The next one is the following in 1967 he had considered the traditional Roman Rite as dead (cf.: Fr. Ratzinger: The Tridentine Mass is a dead liturgy ) and yet he had to meet during this papacy the challenge of the traditional Rite as the living, vivid Divine cult. Outliving the decline of Novus Ordo.
Sandy Barrett shares this
2244
Document restricting the Latin Mass “broke Pope Benedict’s heart” says Archbishop Gänswein
Sandy Barrett
“broke Pope Benedict’s heart”
And: "it hit him pretty hard"
De Profundis
Oh, it broke your heart did it? Maybe you shouldn't have abandoned your post then.
Credo .
Benedict XV1 did flee from the wolves and in doing so he abandoned his flock! Despite the enormity and the consequences of his decision we should also acknowledge his boldness with the retention of the Latin Mass and also for his support of the Society of St. Pius X. > May God have mercy on his soul, and pray that he will intercede for us in Heaven. 🙏 🙏 🙏
laurelmarycecilia
Dear Kenjiro Yoshimori, not sure how in the ordinary scheme of things that can happen. You and I think inside the normal, logical paradigm but .....Have you seen this?
Savannah diocese to end Traditional Latin Masses
Last TLM allowed in Savannah will be May 20, 2023. Bergolio et al., don't need or care if they have anyone's approval. They are dismantling the Church and helping to form a global …More
Dear Kenjiro Yoshimori, not sure how in the ordinary scheme of things that can happen. You and I think inside the normal, logical paradigm but .....Have you seen this?

Savannah diocese to end Traditional Latin Masses

Last TLM allowed in Savannah will be May 20, 2023. Bergolio et al., don't need or care if they have anyone's approval. They are dismantling the Church and helping to form a global religion where "all are welcome"
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
Well, if it goes that way of a "Synodal" global religion where everyone is welcome, including homosexual partners and TRANS, I'd rather turn Greek Orthodox, or just be Christian. But I wouldn't stay a member of the Bergoglia Synodal global "church"
John Fritz Logan
@Kenjiro M. Yoshimori Again, just remain Catholic (whether that mean SSPX, or sede or whatever) don't go Bergoglio, also don't go adultery approving Greek schismatic.
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
@John Fritz Logan -I don't know. Just turning to the SSPX or sedevacantist, somehow I'd feel like I was just "play acting", in a drama that wasn't real. If Pope Francis destroys the Latin Mass, or tries to now that Benedict XVI is gone, I am sure he will be gravely ill within weeks of that act, and have to stand before God to answer for such evil. Even though I am young (and no offense to anyone, …More
@John Fritz Logan -I don't know. Just turning to the SSPX or sedevacantist, somehow I'd feel like I was just "play acting", in a drama that wasn't real. If Pope Francis destroys the Latin Mass, or tries to now that Benedict XVI is gone, I am sure he will be gravely ill within weeks of that act, and have to stand before God to answer for such evil. Even though I am young (and no offense to anyone, but I feel sorry for people who are elderly having to suffer wiith a Church like this), I don't want to spend 50 years (I'd be nearly 80), in a church constantly at battle. I don't envy our family early ancestors in Japan, who were persecuted by the Tokugawa Shogunate for being Catholics, and two were executed. But they did die for the True Mass and Church. I would never suffer and die for the sake of Bergoglio's "church" .
I would like to think that Bergoglio and his people are not such filth that they would take advantage of the death of good Pope Benedict XVI to basically spit on his memory and legacy and destroy his efforts which actually brough much Grace and a small resurgence o the Church. I try to have good Catholic Faith, but if they were do something that low, as to degrade the memory of a good man, then they are TRUELY EVIL, and I don't want to be in a church like that. Greek Orthodox have their faults, but I don't think they are that low. And the very much do have respect for their sacraments. We don't.
Take a look at St. Peter's dome as it looks now. I saw it yesterday. I don't remember it looking black like that. It wasn't the lighting. Something evil is happening in the Church, that even the building is turning ugly. Remember when the two thunderbolts hit St.Peter's the day Benedict XVI annonced that he quit. That wasn't God's anger. THat was the doors opening to Satan.
John Fritz Logan
@Kenjiro M. Yoshimori Well were John the Baptist and the Essenes play acting while living in the desert away from the corrupt second temple while preserving the faith?
You don't wanna spend life in a Church constantly at battle? But that's Christ Church, especially during the end times. If a church does not face immese persecution and infiltration, that's cause the world doesn't hate it enough.
They …More
@Kenjiro M. Yoshimori Well were John the Baptist and the Essenes play acting while living in the desert away from the corrupt second temple while preserving the faith?

You don't wanna spend life in a Church constantly at battle? But that's Christ Church, especially during the end times. If a church does not face immese persecution and infiltration, that's cause the world doesn't hate it enough.

They indeed die for the true Churcj, not for the Greek schism. The Greeks don´t respect the sacrament of marriage. But also, Bergoglio and the group much prefer people going schismatic over going further Trad. They love ecumenics with the Eastern schismatics.

Bishop Schneider, Cardinal Burke, Eijk, Pell, Erdo, Sarah all have done far more for the faith than any Greek bishop.
Clement Jaeho Chung
@John Fritz Logan Happy New Year!! Brother....long time no see!!!! I hope you and all your family,lovely people are always happy, healthy..God bless always you and all your family too....Even though Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI had many mistake, not perfect...but he tried protect to our Orthodox Teaching...I deeply respect his actions....after Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI Retired...Bergoglio got …More
@John Fritz Logan Happy New Year!! Brother....long time no see!!!! I hope you and all your family,lovely people are always happy, healthy..God bless always you and all your family too....Even though Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI had many mistake, not perfect...but he tried protect to our Orthodox Teaching...I deeply respect his actions....after Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI Retired...Bergoglio got to Pope's seat...now we watching to his horrible actions...Pope Benedict totally,totally,totally better than Bergoglio!!! this time..Orthdox teachings are destroying..wrong theory spread to all the world..so terrible..after 9 years..almost 10 years...we got to much horrible situation..these days...I much pray to the Lord..we will get real Pope, Orthodox Pope...Muller, Burke, Sarah, Eijk, Erdo....or another Orthodox Cardianl will elect to Pope...so great!!!! just Lord knows....but my opinion....Lord will choose Eminence Cardinal Eijk...your Archbishop...will be great too!!! be cause he is almost 70 years old....if Lord will choose him...much stay longer possible...and he strongly saying about Gender Ideology's danger....so it's really great Papabili!! Eminence Cardinal Erdo is great too...hmm...we will see...just really hope we can't see another Bergoglio....Lord Sacred Heart of Jesus...please lead to your servant Pope Benedict XVI's soul in to the Kingdom of Heaven....give to him eternal Life!!! Holy Mary, All Angels and Saints..pray for his soul....Amen....many talking sorry....our Lord Sacred Heart of Jesus blessed always you and all your family...all lovely people...Holy Mary, All Angels and Saints..pray for us...Amen...and much, much pray to the Lord...please send us real Pope, Orthodox Pope..fast time!! really want this crazy old man's time will fast gone!!!! Happy New Year Again!! John...take care...I hope learning a lot about your opinion too!!
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
@Clement Jaeho Chung -Happy New Year Clement, to you and your family. I always wanted to ask you a question about South Korea. Even though our family is Catholic, and nearly all of my family both Mom and dad's side have been Catholic for 350+ years (in Japan and USA), we do have Buddhist ancestors 400+ years ago before our family converted. You probably know that Japan is mostly a Buddhist and Shinto …More
@Clement Jaeho Chung -Happy New Year Clement, to you and your family. I always wanted to ask you a question about South Korea. Even though our family is Catholic, and nearly all of my family both Mom and dad's side have been Catholic for 350+ years (in Japan and USA), we do have Buddhist ancestors 400+ years ago before our family converted. You probably know that Japan is mostly a Buddhist and Shinto country (but most people in Japan these days are very secular and don't practice any religion, except at festivals). I was wondering, what percentage of South Korea is still Buddhist? I know about 15% or so is Catholic. But I am a history teacher, and I love history, and I respect the Buddhist traditions, so I was just wondering if South Korea still has a big Buddhist population. I hope so. I also read that South Korea has a lot of fundamentalist Protestant groups. That's not a good thing. I respect the Buddhist tradition much more than fundamental Protestants, even though they are "christian". One of our neighbors are fundamentalist Bible Christians.....but they are very prejudiced. I know that fundamentalist "Christians" hate Catholics. I hope that does not happen in South Korea. It does in the USA sometimes.
Sorry to ask what maybe is a stupid question. I just am interested in Buddhism...not to convert of course, just the history of it. Some of the temples in Japan I've seen are beautiful, and I am sure they are also beautiful in South Korea as well.
Happy New Year to you and your family !
Clement Jaeho Chung
@Kenjiro M. Yoshimori thanks for telling me..Kenjiro....first...in Korea..maybe 21% is Buddhist person...yes..I respect Buddhist too...they have their rules..and have long history...and korea have some temples too..it's nice....and maybe 17% are Protestant....Catholic people are maybe 11%!!! in korean protestant....hmm...I can't explain deeply...not everybody bad...but have many problems!! you are …More
@Kenjiro M. Yoshimori thanks for telling me..Kenjiro....first...in Korea..maybe 21% is Buddhist person...yes..I respect Buddhist too...they have their rules..and have long history...and korea have some temples too..it's nice....and maybe 17% are Protestant....Catholic people are maybe 11%!!! in korean protestant....hmm...I can't explain deeply...not everybody bad...but have many problems!! you are 100% correct!!!! and in Korean catholic church...after Bergoglio got Papacy...going to lost way....decrease population....attend to mass are low....very difficult situation!!! and I told you....my now Archbishop..Archbishop Peter Cheong...following to LGBT Ideologies...totally difference than former Archbishop...Cardinal Andrew Yeom...hmm....and Kenjiro....you told..if, if Bergoglio's church will change, destroying to our Orthodox teachings..join to Orthodox, or just be Christian....totally understand!! but I hope tell....please staying in here....me...even though have many sins..have so many fault...but, but if changing...I am going to go to Underground church....Japan and Korea have a lot of great Martyrs....but yes...I totally agree....that time..both countries Martyrs died for Our Lord...that time...Vatican many effort Protect to our Orthodox teachings.....but if, if Bergoglio will change...ah...but I hope see the Lord!!! so tell this..many talking sorry...always really happy to see your opinions...I learning a lot....Happy New Year Again....and much pray..Lord will send us real Pope too...God bless always you and all your family, lovely people!!!! Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI gone....so hard time...
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
@Clement Jaeho Chung -Thank you Clement for answering my question! I've never been to Korea, but me and my family go back to Japan to visit relatives every two years....last time I was there was 2019 though, because of COVID-19 we didn't go 2020 or 2022. Hopefully maybe this year!!
Thanks for telling me the percentages of Buddhists and Protestants and Catholics in Korea. I'm a history teacher, so …More
@Clement Jaeho Chung -Thank you Clement for answering my question! I've never been to Korea, but me and my family go back to Japan to visit relatives every two years....last time I was there was 2019 though, because of COVID-19 we didn't go 2020 or 2022. Hopefully maybe this year!!
Thanks for telling me the percentages of Buddhists and Protestants and Catholics in Korea. I'm a history teacher, so I'm always interested in the history of different countries. I am always proud of my ancestry, and I also am interested in Korea and China.
I'm sorry that your new Archbishop supports the LGBTQ agenda. He is a Bergoglio appointment, so I am not surprised.
I hope you are watching the coverage of th ceremonies in Rome for Pope Benedict XVI. God bless our late great Holy Father. Apparently, close to 100,000 people have already come to view Pope Benedict's body as it rests in St. Peter's Basilica. The liberals in the Vatican are very surprised, and not happy, than so many people are coming to pray for and visit Benedict XVI 1 last time. His funeral is on Thursday. I hope they get 250,000+ in St. Peter's Square for his funeral. He was a great Pope.
I am always impressed by your comments here. You have great faith! I am not as holy!
I think Bergoglio is going to resign very soon. This might be a blessing. I think his plans will fail, because so many people in Rome and elsewhere hate him, that I think he will just quit. I hope so.
Happy New Year again to you! Thanks for answering my question. I was always curious about religion in Korea. We have alot of fundamentalist Protestants here too. Some are not that bad, but some groups are fanatics and that's bad.
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
Benedict XVI will be more harm to Bergoglio and his agenda dead than he ever could be alive. Benedict XVI was one good man, trying to correct the liturgical injustices in the Church. But now, Summorum Pontificum has given rise to a army of tens of thousands. If Bergoglio goes after them again trying to bring them down, not only will he bring down instead the Novus Ordo, but his entire agenda, …More
Benedict XVI will be more harm to Bergoglio and his agenda dead than he ever could be alive. Benedict XVI was one good man, trying to correct the liturgical injustices in the Church. But now, Summorum Pontificum has given rise to a army of tens of thousands. If Bergoglio goes after them again trying to bring them down, not only will he bring down instead the Novus Ordo, but his entire agenda, pontificate, and any legacy.
Kenjiro M. Yoshimori
I would be alittle more charitable, but actually he was cowardly to quit. But God Bless Pope Benedict XVI regardless, and may the angels lead him into Paradise.
rhemes1582
@Sator 369 I agree they should have strongly been supporting him!
Unfortunately the Church is in such a sad state, even good men struggle with hard decisions.
All above orders I'm sure worried, and worry about their flock and preservation of Catholic worship. We fear our shepherds
God Help usMore
@Sator 369 I agree they should have strongly been supporting him!
Unfortunately the Church is in such a sad state, even good men struggle with hard decisions.
All above orders I'm sure worried, and worry about their flock and preservation of Catholic worship. We fear our shepherds

God Help us
Credo .
@ rhemes 1582 @Sator 369 I concur with your sentiments! > 🙏 🙏 🙏