15 pages
The attached document, translated by Mr. Anthony Pointing (England) is, to my knowledge, the first ever complete English-language translation of Fr. Alvaro Calderon’s 2014 SiSiNoNo study on the new (…More
The attached document, translated by Mr. Anthony Pointing (England) is, to my knowledge, the first ever complete English-language translation of Fr. Alvaro Calderon’s 2014 SiSiNoNo study on the new (1968) rite of episcopal consecration.
Fr. Calderon is a longtime professor at the SSPX seminary in La Reja, Argentina, and alongside Fr. Pierre-Marie, O.P. (Avrille, France), is reputed by +Williamson to be one of the two best theologians in all of Tradition.
Although Fr. Calderon’s study concludes that the NREC is “very probably valid,” it likewise acknowledges “a shadow of doubt” hangs over it because of inherent ambiguities.
Sean Johnson
PDF attached.
Martin G Machine shares this
2354
Martin G Machine
Would it be possible to put this online as a pdf in order to make it easy to download? Thank you
Sean Johnson
PDF attached above.
FAITH HOPE CHARITY
A little known fact about the creation of this study [ a study of the Novus Ordo Missae] was that Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre chaired the working committee that drafted it. Historical details about this important event can be found in Marcel Lefebvre: The Biography by Bishop Bernard Tissier de Mallerais.[1]
As briefly related by Fr. Ramon Angles in his transcribed conference, “A Short History of …More
A little known fact about the creation of this study [ a study of the Novus Ordo Missae] was that Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre chaired the working committee that drafted it. Historical details about this important event can be found in Marcel Lefebvre: The Biography by Bishop Bernard Tissier de Mallerais.[1]

As briefly related by Fr. Ramon Angles in his transcribed conference, “A Short History of the Society of St. Pius X”:[2]

On April 3, 1969, the apostolic constitution Missale Romanum presented a new order of the Mass. Archbishop Lefebvre gathered together a group of 12 theologians who wrote under his direction, "A Short Critical Study of the Novus Ordo Missae" often called the "Ottaviani Intervention". Cardinals Ottaviani and Bacci wrote indeed an introduction and presented the study to Paul VI. Since no response came from the Vatican, the archbishop announces to his small group of seminarians, June 10, 1971, that he refuses to accept this new protestantized liturgy:

'How can I agree to abandon the Mass of All Time or to admit to place it at the same level as the Novus Ordo, created by Annibal Bugnini, with the participation of Protestants to make of it an equivocal supper that eliminates totally the Offertory, and touches the very words of the Consecration.'"
Sean Johnson
Yes, but this thread is about the new rite of episcopal consecration, not the new rite of Mass.
FAITH HOPE CHARITY
This is off topic.
This is to point out to the SSPX ordinary parishioners today who have no idea that the SSPX is not according to how it was founded by A. Lefebvre. The bergoglian church will sooner or later implement that the SSPX must further establish/prove their ''union'' with Rome as has been done already but in mostly unknown small and hidden ways.More
This is off topic.

This is to point out to the SSPX ordinary parishioners today who have no idea that the SSPX is not according to how it was founded by A. Lefebvre. The bergoglian church will sooner or later implement that the SSPX must further establish/prove their ''union'' with Rome as has been done already but in mostly unknown small and hidden ways.
Sean Johnson
Ah yes, it’s very true that most of those post-2010 sspxers never knew the unbranded/sanatized sspx. Unfortunately, many long timers simply went with the flow, and pretend there have been no changes.
Tony La Rosa
Do you have a pdf available?
Sean Johnson
Emailing it to you now
Tony La Rosa
I received it. Thank you, Sean!