That's a ridiculous reply...nonsense!

You are doing what you accuse others of doing: being "judgy". That accusation: "You people on this website are so 'judgy' " is also being "judgy". Since you claim that argument is "nonsense" then YOU must show how your judgement of people on this website is NOT being "judgy". Good luck. ;-)

There is a place and a time for everything we are all free to comment up to our conscience and have a good conversation

That is true. In my parish, I see women and old,old nuns (habitless femminists of course), going up to the altar, opening the tabranacle, and handing out hosts for "Eucharistic ministers" to the sick, as if they were cookies. No genuflection, no respect. Typical of everything from the Vatican II Church. I am ashamed of it, from Pope on down, and am sorry that I've been stuck growing up in the Vatican II Church in the 90's-early 2000's, just as my parents were stuck in the late 1960's. I envy the kind of great Pope and Church my grandparents grew up with in the 1930's-40's, even though it was in Japan and not Philadelphia, Pa.

I love the Latin Mass-but if the Novus Ordo is invalid explain the Eucharistic miracles that happen during and from it.