en.news

Vatican Dismisses Appeal by Transalpine Redemptorists

On 10 August, the Diocese of Christchurch, New Zealand, announced that the Vatican had dismissed the appeal by the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer, also known as the Transalpine Redemptorists.

The order celebrates Mass in the Roman rite. They had appealed against directives and decrees issued by Bishop Michael Gielen in July 2024.

What happened in 2024?

In July 2023, 17 people accused the order of spiritual and psychological abuse and of performing exorcisms without permission from the Christchurch diocese. The Order denied the allegations.

In July 2024, following an apostolic visitation and a list of recommendations from the Vatican’s Congregation for Religious, Bishop Gielen published a series of harsh measures. He suspended the priests and ordered all members of the order to leave the diocese.

In September 2024, the diocese stressed that public Masses conducted by these priests are deemed illicit.

In a statement released in November 2024, the community replied that the measures were unjust and that they intended to remain in Christchurch while the case proceeded.

Now that the appeal has been dismissed, the diocese says that the original measures stand in full.

The order came to Christchurch in 2007.

#newsGwpcennuxh
31.7K
K R Ross

Sad, Fr. Michael Mary Sim, conditionally ordained by Abp Lefebvre, at Fr. Sim's request, after leaving the modernist Redemptorists in the late eighties, should have just stayed with the FSSPX. The arguments that the Transalpine Redemptorists are using are the same as those used by Abp Lefebvre when the FSSPX was unjustly censured by Mgr Mamie and by Rome, and labelled "un seminaire sauvage." They now find themselves in the same boat as the FSSPX when it started, using the same arguments of "unjust censure."

Since the monastery was canonically instituted, I believe the bishop is dead wrong in trying to force the N.O. on these priests. If it was legal once, it is difficult to make it illegal now.

Insanity is explained by a person committing the same mistake and expecting a different result. Vatican II is a counterfeit religion.