Mariologists Rebuke Tucho's Document as Erroneous and Unfortunate
In a 23-page response, the International Marian Association Theological Commission (IMA) highlights what it sees as significant errors and omissions in Cardinal Tucho Fernández’s doctrinal note Mater Populi Fidelis. Key phrases:
- If the title Co-redemptrix is always inappropriate or inopportune to use, then the popes, saints and mystics who approved or used the title were acting in an inappropriate and imprudent manner.
- Members of the IMA Theological Commission who have taught Mariology for decades certainly do not find the title Co-redemptrix ‘unhelpful’.
- While it is appropriate that Mater Populi Fidelis acknowledges papal uses of the title Co-redemptrix, it is unfortunate that these papal uses are not given greater respect or presence in the actual text.
- It is unusual that a doctrinal note of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith would quote at length a secular interview by a cardinal prefect, and at the same time, not include over ten papal usages of the same title. …More
The tragedy of Fernandez and Leo XIV is that they know the IMA's arguments very well, but they wilfully ignore the truth. In complete accordance with the modernism they adhere to.
Top Mariologists condemn Vatican’s discouragement of Co-Redemptrix title
Let's face it - this is all on Prevost's watch. He kept Tucho on, and he signed off on this spurious, and generally unnecessary document. Taking a Mary down a few pegs is genuinely the most pressing matter of the Faith at the moment?! Really?!! Perhaps Prevost and Tucho needs to be re-examined.
For the record:
Faithful Worldwide Petition Prevost to Re-examine “Mater Populi Fidelis”
Now we see the figure of an inverted schism: all those who have joined Prevost and Bergoglio have joined their rebellion against God and the Church, and whether they know it or not, passively or actively, they have separated themselves from Christ and His Church. Just like the apostate angels who joined Lucifer's rebellion. That is why it is necessary to separate ourselves from Prevost and reject all of Bergoglio's anti-magisterium.